Saturday 9 February 2013

I hold them accountable, and find them wanting


Politics has always fascinated me. Where people draw the line and say no further, and where they don't see lines that others do. It's probably why I'm such a bore to be around. In many ways I'm grateful to be British and have our peculiar oddities in law, because when I look at American politics a lot of the lines on the sand seemed to be based merely off what the other side was promoting. It comes across as pathetically petty. Of course, in contrast, I get a House of Commons that is unwatchable because it's such uncomfortable viewing watching grown men jeer and mock and shriek like children at one another, so it's all swings and roundabouts. (If you are wondering that I only added that last phrase to mess with any Americans that wandered into this lonely corner of the internet, I admit nothing.) I mention this today as we've recently passed the first reading of an amendment to our law that would enable marriage to be equal on grounds of gender.

Watch out people. We're going to let our gays marry. Le horror.

What strikes me as particularly interesting is the differences of mentality of the sides of debate. One the one hand we have a very passionate bunch of people, who are very robust in denouncing this change as debilitating the term and act of marriage, with zeal that is only ramped up when religion is brought into it. On the other side, the mentality seems to be more... like a shrug, really. I've yet to see people as passionate as the 'no' side. For clarity's sake, I'm not saying their aren't people who feel very strongly in approval of gay marriage, their definitely are, but I've yet to see someone match the rate of manic zeal the 'no' side trots out.

For me, if you burst into my place of work, grasped me roughly by the shoulders and demanded my opinion on equal marriage rights, I would (after politely removing your hands from my shoulders) shrug and say, 'Sure. Why not?' And that's it. It doesn't take anything away from me. I am aware that marriage is a whole host of legal rights, and, well, a section of law-abiding society is denied access to it currently, which is unfair, so that should be corrected. My passion for it is to see an injustice corrected. I am aware of the counter arguments. I have decided that they are all irrelevant. No, it won't take anything away from current married couples. No, it won't lead to animal marriages in the same vein that letting women have the vote hasn't led us to dogs having the vote. No, teachers aren't going to be forced to teach that being gay is the best thing ever and all the cool kids are doing it, and let's face it, we already have gay couples who've been taking their kids to school for a while now, those kids have already got the gist that some couple don't strictly come in the 'Mum + Dad' category. No, marriage is not an untouchable bastion, we used to forcibly marry off women all the time in treaty negotiations and that changed, oh, hey, also remember when the law changed so it was recognized that a married women could be raped by her husband when before that was impossible? Anyone? So this also, can change. There are probably more arguments against, but honestly, not one has ever come close to sounding convincing and I don't have the patience to continue.

Do you want to know a secret? Once, I found a single argument against equal marriage that I felt sorta held weight. Wanna know what it was? Say a kid has two dads. One is called 'daddy.' So. What is the other one called? WHAT DO YOU CALL THE SECOND BLOKE?

Then I read a sweet G2 article where a couple said that he was 'daddy,' and his partner was 'papa.'

At this point, I threw up my hands, and declared the debate over. Equal marriage. No counter arguments worth having. Done.

It's a curious thing. For some people, this is a Big Bad Thing worth getting very incensed over, whilst a lot of the opposing side it's a big deal in that it's a wrong to be fixed, but not one they're going to go red in the face at. It might just be because in this country most of us are for equal marriage rights, so the pro side aren't massively emotional as there's not a bitter fight to be fought. They're going to win, it just takes time, why work yourself up about something a few die-hards can gripe and scream about but not prevent? Of course, this could all just be me projecting, but seriously, I have read the counter-arguments. They bore me. As said, I have deemed them irreverent. So have many others. Move over already, and if it really bothers you, don't marry a person of the same gender and you'll be fine.

Besides, it seems like they're missing an important point. I mean, let's be honest everyone...

Um. What was I doing again?
...those women. Are hawt. Regardless of internal or external sexual organs. Look, Natelie Portman was in the Star Wars prequels and I still find her unintelligible-speech hot. That's sufficient hotness to overcome nerd rage, it's more than hot enough to make a fellow woman go 'Daaaaaaaayum.'

Also she studied like, four languages, went to Harvard, has had scientific papers published and - shut up me shut up me - oh hey Christina was YoSaffBridge in Firefly which was one of the best sci-fi - shut up shut up shut up.

Anyway. Lesbianism doesn't squick out men so much nowadays, (many the complete opposite) so in the interest of being completely and utterly honest with ourselves...

What's the phrase? 'No homo?'
I am a straight male. Boobs are like the best thing, evar. And as a straight straighterty straighterson male... that is one pretty man.

I said it.

Unff. One pretty man.

Of course, if I was being really honest with you, I'd say that personally...

In my defense; Google search has his name immediately followed by 'shirtless.' Just sayin'
I find him prettier. Unff.

Ahem. Anyway. Back to the original point. I'm for equal marriage, but I'm not massively emotional on the subject bar the fact it would be nice, to, you know, start treating people equally and everything, which not doing so is not cool.

However my emotional feelings on the people – not the sides – are very different. Because I am tempered in feeling for my side, it doesn't mean I can't get a real mad on what the other side is pushing. Sure, you can be on the other side of a debate on me. But in this case, by attempting to needlessly block equality to a group of people that already take more than their far share of shite from society? By entrenching yourself with a side that I have not found one single goddamn argument to hold any bloody weight? Just how, just how fucking privileged are you? Why, in that case, that makes you, your right honourable selves, some complete and massive pricks.

And hey, I was thinking to myself, 'Wow. Those are some class A douchebags there. Voting against it. Isn't it a pity that we've heard all the nonsense arguments, yet they won't retreat. Man, I wish I could, in some way, hold them accountable for their actions. Why, I wish I knew who voted against it, so I could look at their names, and always remember to treat them with utter contempt and be sure I, or anyone else, never ever elect them to office again.'

And then I got an idea. A terrible, wonderful, idea. I have a blog. Obviously. Duh. Some of you must agree with me, unless you're here to be angry at my world views or because you take a perverse sexual thrill in spelling and grammatical errors. And some of those who agree with me may just reside in my county. So. What's stopping me from, say, going to www.publicwhip.org.uk and publishing a list of all those who voted against (and abstained) so that we could hold those that hold some pretty detestable views accountable for their shit?

Name Constituency Party Vote
Adam Afriyie Windsor Con no
Peter Aldous Waveney Con no
David Amess Southend West Con no
James Arbuthnot North East Hampshire Con no
Richard Bacon South Norfolk Con no
Steven Baker Wycombe Con no
Tony Baldry Banbury Con no
Guto Bebb Aberconwy Con no
Henry Bellingham North West Norfolk Con no
Paul Beresford Mole Valley Con no
Andrew Bingham High Peak Con no
Bob Blackman Harrow East Con no
Peter Bone Wellingborough Con tellno
Graham Brady Altrincham and Sale West Con no
Julian Brazier Canterbury Con no
Andrew Bridgen North West Leicestershire Con no
Steve Brine Winchester Con no
Fiona Bruce Congleton Con no
Robert Buckland South Swindon Con no
Simon Burns Chelmsford Con no
David Burrowes Enfield, Southgate Con no
Alun Cairns Vale of Glamorgan Con no
Douglas Carswell Clacton Con no
William Cash Stone Con no
Rehman Chishti Gillingham and Rainham Con no
Christopher Chope Christchurch Con no
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown The Cotswolds Con no
Therese Coffey Suffolk Coastal Con tellno
Geoffrey Cox Torridge and West Devon Con no
Stephen Crabb Preseli Pembrokeshire Con no
David Davies Monmouth Con no
Glyn Davies Montgomeryshire Con no
Philip Davies Shipley Con no
David Davis Haltemprice and Howden Con no
Nick de Bois Enfield North Con no
Caroline Dinenage Gosport Con no
Nadine Dorries Mid Bedfordshire Con no
Richard Drax South Dorset Con no
Charlie Elphicke Dover Con no
Jonathan Evans Cardiff North Con no
David Evennett Bexleyheath and Crayford Con no
Michael Fallon Sevenoaks Con no
Liam Fox North Somerset Con no
Mark Francois Rayleigh and Wickford Con no
George Freeman Mid Norfolk Con no
Roger Gale North Thanet Con no
Edward Garnier Harborough Con no
Mark Garnier Wyre Forest Con no
Cheryl Gillan Chesham and Amersham Con no
John Glen Salisbury Con no
Robert Goodwill Scarborough and Whitby Con no
James Gray North Wiltshire Con no
Andrew Griffiths Burton Con no
Robert Halfon Harlow Con no
Simon Hart Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire Con no
Alan Haselhurst Saffron Walden Con no
John Hayes South Holland and The Deepings Con no
Oliver Heald North East Hertfordshire Con no
Gordon Henderson Sittingbourne and Sheppey Con no
Philip Hollobone Kettering Con no
Adam Holloway Gravesham Con no
Gerald Howarth Aldershot Con no
Stewart Jackson Peterborough Con no
Gareth Johnson Dartford Con no
David Jones Clwyd West Con no
Marcus Jones Nuneaton Con no
Greg Knight East Yorkshire Con no
Kwasi Kwarteng Spelthorne Con no
Mark Lancaster Milton Keynes North Con no
Pauline Latham Mid Derbyshire Con no
Jeremy Lefroy Stafford Con no
Edward Leigh Gainsborough Con no
Julian Lewis New Forest East Con no
David Lidington Aylesbury Con no
Peter Lilley Hitchin and Harpenden Con no
Jack Lopresti Filton and Bradley Stoke Con no
Jonathan Lord Woking Con no
Tim Loughton East Worthing and Shoreham Con no
Karen Lumley Redditch Con no
Anne Main St Albans Con no
Paul Maynard Blackpool North and Cleveleys Con no
Karl McCartney Lincoln Con no
Anne McIntosh Thirsk and Malton Con no
Stephen McPartland Stevenage Con no
Esther McVey Wirral West Con no
Stephen Metcalfe South Basildon and East Thurrock Con no
Nicky Morgan Loughborough Con no
Anne-Marie Morris Newton Abbot Con no
David Morris Morecambe and Lunesdale Con no
James Morris Halesowen and Rowley Regis Con no
Bob Neill Bromley and Chislehurst Con no
Caroline Nokes Romsey and Southampton North Con no
David Nuttall Bury North Con no
Stephen O'Brien Eddisbury Con no
Matthew Offord Hendon Con no
James Paice South East Cambridgeshire Con no
Neil Parish Tiverton and Honiton Con no
Priti Patel Witham Con no
Owen Paterson North Shropshire Con no
Mark Pawsey Rugby Con no
Michael Penning Hemel Hempstead Con no
Mark Pritchard The Wrekin Con no
John Randall Uxbridge and South Ruislip Con no
John Redwood Wokingham Con no
Jacob Rees-Mogg North East Somerset Con no
Simon Reevell Dewsbury Con no
Malcolm Rifkind Kensington Con no
Andrew Robathan South Leicestershire Con no
Laurence Robertson Tewkesbury Con no
Andrew Rosindell Romford Con no
David Ruffley Bury St Edmunds Con no
David Rutley Macclesfield Con no
Andrew Selous South West Bedfordshire Con no
Alec Shelbrooke Elmet and Rothwell Con no
Richard Shepherd Aldridge-Brownhills Con no
Henry Smith Crawley Con no
John Stanley Tonbridge and Malling Con no
John Stevenson Carlisle Con no
Bob Stewart Beckenham Con no
Mel Stride Central Devon Con no
Julian Sturdy York Outer Con no
Robert Syms Poole Con no
Peter Tapsell Louth and Horncastle Con no
David Tredinnick Bosworth Con no
Andrew Turner Isle of Wight Con no
Shailesh Vara North West Cambridgeshire Con no
Martin Vickers Cleethorpes Con no
Ben Wallace Wyre and Preston North Con no
Robert Walter North Dorset Con no
James Wharton Stockton South Con no
Heather Wheeler South Derbyshire Con no
Craig Whittaker Calder Valley Con no
John Whittingdale Maldon Con no
Bill Wiggin North Herefordshire Con no
Gavin Williamson South Staffordshire Con no
Jeremy Wright Kenilworth and Southam Con no
Angie Bray Ealing Central and Acton Con both
Andrea Leadsom South Northamptonshire Con both
Phillip Lee Bracknell Con both
Charlotte Leslie Bristol North West Con both
Rob Wilson Reading East Con both
Harriett Baldwin West Worcestershire Con absent
Stephen Barclay North East Cambridgeshire Con absent
Jake Berry Rossendale and Darwen Con absent
Brian Binley Northampton South Con absent
Nicola Blackwood Oxford West and Abingdon Con absent
Jonathan Djanogly Huntingdon Con absent
Jackie Doyle-Price Thurrock Con absent
Philip Dunne Ludlow Con absent
Tobias Ellwood Bournemouth East Con absent
George Eustice Camborne and Redruth Con absent
Graham Evans Weaver Vale Con absent
Nigel Evans Ribble Valley Con absent
Richard Fuller Bedford Con absent
Dominic Grieve Beaconsfield Con absent
Philip Hammond Runnymede and Weybridge Con absent
Rebecca Harris Castle Point Con absent
Mark Hoban Fareham Con absent
Nick Hurd Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner Con absent
Chris Kelly Dudley South Con absent
Eleanor Laing Epping Forest Con absent
Ian Liddell-Grainger Bridgwater and West Somerset Con absent
Patrick Mercer Newark Con absent
Anne Milton Guildford Con absent
Sheryll Murray South East Cornwall Con absent
Jesse Norman Hereford and South Herefordshire Con absent
Claire Perry Devizes Con absent
Stephen Phillips Sleaford and North Hykeham Con absent
Mark Prisk Hertford and Stortford Con absent
Lee Scott Ilford North Con absent
Mark Spencer Sherwood Con absent
Gary Streeter South West Devon Con absent
Graham Stuart Beverley and Holderness Con absent
Edward Timpson Crewe and Nantwich Con absent
Andrew Tyrie Chichester Con absent
Paul Uppal Wolverhampton South West Con absent
Nadhim Zahawi Stratford-on-Avon Con absent
Gregory Campbell East Londonderry DUP no
Nigel Dodds Belfast North DUP no
Jeffrey M Donaldson Lagan Valley DUP no
William McCrea South Antrim DUP no
Ian Paisley Jnr North Antrim DUP no
Jim Shannon Strangford DUP no
David Simpson Upper Bann DUP no
Sammy Wilson East Antrim DUP no
Lady Hermon North Down Ind no
Joe Benton Bootle Lab no
Ronnie Campbell Blyth Valley Lab no
Tom Clarke Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill Lab no
Rosie Cooper West Lancashire Lab no
David Crausby Bolton North East Lab no
Tony Cunningham Workington Lab no
Jim Dobbin Heywood and Middleton Lab no
Brian H Donohoe Central Ayrshire Lab no
Robert Flello Stoke-on-Trent South Lab no
Mary Glindon North Tyneside Lab no
Paul Goggins Wythenshawe and Sale East Lab no
Dai Havard Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney Lab no
Michael McCann East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow Lab no
Jim McGovern Dundee West Lab no
Iain McKenzie Inverclyde Lab no
George Mudie Leeds East Lab no
Paul Murphy Torfaen Lab no
Stephen Pound Ealing North Lab no
Frank Roy Motherwell and Wishaw Lab no
Jim Sheridan Paisley and Renfrewshire North Lab no
Derek Twigg Halton Lab no
Mike Wood Batley and Spen Lab no
Anne Begg Aberdeen South Lab absent
Gordon Brown Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath Lab absent
Alex Cunningham Stockton North Lab absent
Bill Esterson Sefton Central Lab absent
Pat Glass North West Durham Lab absent
Roger Godsiff Birmingham, Hall Green Lab absent
David Heyes Ashton-under-Lyne Lab absent
Jimmy Hood Lanark and Hamilton East Lab absent
Lindsay Hoyle Chorley Lab absent
Khalid Mahmood Birmingham, Perry Barr Lab absent
Michael Meacher Oldham West and Royton Lab absent
Ian Mearns Gateshead Lab absent
Dawn Primarolo Bristol South Lab absent
Yasmin Qureshi Bolton South East Lab absent
Virendra Sharma Ealing, Southall Lab absent
Gavin Shuker Luton South Lab absent
Stephen Timms East Ham Lab absent
Shaun Woodward St Helens South and Whiston Lab absent
Alan Beith Berwick-upon-Tweed LDem no
Gordon Birtwistle Burnley LDem no
John Pugh Southport LDem no
Sarah Teather Brent Central LDem no
Norman Baker Lewes LDem absent
Martin Horwood Cheltenham LDem absent
Charles Kennedy Ross, Skye and Lochaber LDem absent
Greg Mulholland Leeds North West LDem absent
John Thurso Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross LDem absent
David Ward Bradford East LDem absent
Jennifer Willott Cardiff Central LDem absent
Alasdair McDonnell Belfast South SDLP absent
Margaret Ritchie South Down SDLP absent
Pat Doherty West Tyrone SF absent
Michelle Gildernew Fermanagh and South Tyrone SF absent
Paul Maskey Belfast West SF absent
Conor Murphy Newry and Armagh SF absent
Stewart Hosie Dundee East SNP absent
Angus MacNeil Na h-Eileanan an Iar SNP absent
Angus Robertson Moray SNP absent
Michael Weir Angus SNP absent
Eilidh Whiteford Banff and Buchan SNP absent
Pete Wishart Perth and North Perthshire SNP absent
John Bercow Buckingham Speaker absent

Absolutely bloody nothing, it turns out. Ctrl+F and see if your representative turns up, because mine bloody well did. Deep joy. 

I took all names from the Public Whip, original link here: http://www.publicwhip.org.uk/division.php?date=2013-02-05&number=151&display=allpossible

If I placed someone's name in error, please let me know and I'll edit it as soon as possible.

*it turns out we have tellers and can vote both or something? I... whatever. The Public Whip does explain, and I like politics, but even I can have my brain shut down in self-defense from reading political jargon.


No comments:

Post a Comment